Is Corporate Overreach Different than Government Overreach?

Honeywell International made news this week when it was reported that the company was putting conditions on employee health and lifestyle when determining the health care costs Honeywell would cover.  This, of course, should raise some concerns about corporate intrusion into private lives.  Jon Tevlin at the Star Tribune did just that.

In a broader stroke, I want to comment quickly about this example.  Many people from all political persuasions seem to think that government is somehow the entity that threatens privacy and freedom, but this is hardly the case.  Directly and indirectly, business, not government, sets rules that affect everyone.  Consumer choice dwindles in everything from personal credit to where you can work.  It’s a vise that squeezes so-called free market options as those options become more scarce.

The scope of government interference in the lives of Americans is really quite limited and most of this “interference” deals with things we support for good reason.  You cannot flush your toilet into a river or walk away from a contract, for example.

We cannot keep thinking government is the problem.  In most cases it isn’t.  And that isn’t to say that a private business therefore is the problem.  That isn’t true either.  Business also has interests it needs to protect.  However, the next time someone suggests that privatization is the best answer, ask why.


One thought on “Is Corporate Overreach Different than Government Overreach?

  1. Gary Farland

    We have a system where owners of capital get to have great control over those who have only their labor to offer. Of course, it used to be much worse prior to the Roosevelts. Now technology is giving back to capital owners unfettered control, done with the assistance of government. I’m thinking of writing a book about future called “2084”.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s